Free delivery with parcel machines on orders 49 eur

A pet is the greatest gift. But should you give an animal as a present?

Back to Health corner
A pet is the greatest gift, FendaF Health Corner

A pet is the greatest gift. But should you give an animal as a present?

Reading time: about 6 min

I once read Karen Shaw Becker’s thoughts about five gifts our pets bring us every day. They genuinely made me reflect. Our dogs have changed my life far more than any gift bought in a shop could. Yet there is an important contradiction here: a pet can be the greatest gift in our lives without ever being handed to somebody as a surprise present.

I say that from personal experience. As a child, I arranged for a friend to give me a rat for my birthday because my mother would never have allowed me to get one otherwise. Fortunately, my mother was understanding and the rat was allowed to stay, as long as it did not escape from my room. Back then, it seemed like a clever solution. As an adult, I realise that I had put both my mother and the animal in a situation they had never agreed to together.

Five gifts an animal can give a person

The first is connection. Living with a pet gradually creates a relationship that is about much more than feeding times and walks. A dog learns our habits, while we learn to read its body language. That is how a shared life takes shape. It does not mean an animal understands us unconditionally or is always happy with everything. Closeness requires attention from both sides.

The second is communication. Dogs tell us a great deal through their bodies and behaviour: they may want to move away, play, ask for space or show discomfort. Learning to notice these signals often helps us pay closer attention to our own body language too. Teaching a dog should not be all about giving commands. It should also involve listening.

The third is being present. When you give your dog time to sniff and explore on a woodland walk, you may find yourself slowing down as well. I would not claim that animals never remember the past or anticipate the future. They learn from experience and can predict what comes next. Yet their immediate responses often bring our attention back to the present moment.

The fourth is the opportunity to make amends. We make mistakes when living with animals: sometimes we react impatiently or overlook their needs. A dog may seek contact again quickly, but that does not mean a bad experience has had no effect. Restoring trust requires us to take responsibility for our behaviour and protect the animal’s sense of safety.

The fifth is routine and balance. A dog needs food, movement, rest and opportunities for natural, species-appropriate activities. Those daily walks and routines sometimes make me look up from my own work too. A pet is not a therapy device or a solution to every problem, but the relationship can give a day a very welcome rhythm.

Why can giving an animal as a surprise be a bad idea?

Around the holidays, it is easy to imagine a puppy sitting under the Christmas tree. But an animal is not an object that can be put back on a shelf when the excitement fades. It has its own character, needs and sometimes health problems. The next ten or more years will be shaped by countless ordinary days, not by one adorable moment.

I want to be precise here. We cannot claim that every animal received as a gift inevitably ends up worse off. Research does not justify such a sweeping conclusion. The real concern is the surprise and the lack of a say in the decision: does the future caregiver actually want the animal, can they meet its needs, and are they prepared for long-term responsibility?

If a family has decided together to adopt an animal, researched suitable options, discussed the costs of care and, where possible, met the particular animal, its arrival may well happen to fall during the holidays. What matters is not the calendar date but whether the decision was carefully considered.

A child’s pet is not a child’s toy

Children can love animals deeply. That does not remove the adult’s responsibility. A child may help with feeding, walk a dog under adult supervision or take part in daily care, but ultimate responsibility for food, veterinary treatment, safety and welfare remains with the adult. This needs to be understood before the first puppy, kitten or small rodent arrives.

My rat story illustrates it well. I wanted that animal, but for my mother it was an unexpected responsibility. We were fortunate, yet my little scheme was not a fair way to reach a shared decision.

Think about real life before bringing an animal home

How long might the animal live? How much exercise or enrichment will it need each day? Are there allergies, young children or other animals in the household? What happens during holidays, illness, moving house or a change in workload? Can the budget cover routine expenses as well as unexpected veterinary care?

With a dog, it is not enough that the animal physically fits in your home. Some need plenty of activity, others more quiet time, and an older animal may need different care from a puppy. An adult rescue animal may be a wonderful match for one family and the wrong fit for another. Suitability matters more than how wonderful its picture looks on social media.

Breeder, shelter and a responsible choice

If you want a pedigree dog, research the breeder, the breed’s health risks and the health tests of the parents. Ask to see where the puppies are raised and discuss honestly what sort of dog suits your lifestyle. Do not support a seller who rushes the decision, refuses to share essential information or will not show how the animals live. If something worries you, seek advice from a competent animal welfare organisation.

The same principle applies when adopting from a shelter: the decision should be considered carefully and match the animal’s needs. You do not have to adopt an animal on impulse if your home cannot provide long-term safety. Good intentions and good outcomes are not always the same thing.

How much time do we really give our animals?

I remember talking to a dog owner in the FendaF showroom about what a huge responsibility having a dog is. I had recently been thinking that, even though our dogs spend much of the day with us, perhaps only two or three hours of my attention are entirely theirs. The rest of the time I am working, cooking, watching something or doing other things. Being next to a dog is not quite the same as spending time with it.

That thought need not turn into guilt. But it is a useful question before adopting another animal: does my day have room not only for its basic care but for genuinely spending time together? Not just on Christmas Eve or during the first week, but for months and years to come.

If you want to give an animal lover something truly meaningful

You could offer a walk together, dog training, a suitable activity for their animal or help them learn about different animals’ needs. If getting a pet is a joint decision, a lovely symbolic gift might be an agreement: we will choose an animal together when everybody is ready. The animal itself should not be chosen because of wrapping paper and a particular date.

In conclusion

A pet can be the greatest gift because it changes our daily lives, teaches us to listen and creates a very special bond. That is precisely why it should not be a random surprise present. To me, bringing an animal home is a promise to care for it long after the first excitement has faded. That is a far bigger decision than any present under a Christmas tree.

Sources

  • Karen Shaw Becker. Five Gifts Your Pet Brings You (2022)
  • American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA). Responsible Pet Ownership

🐾 FendaF believes in informed choices

The purpose of the FendaF blog is not to tell you what you must do. Our aim is to share knowledge, introduce different evidence-based and integrative perspectives, and help you make more informed decisions for your pet.

Every animal is unique, and no article can replace a consultation, diagnosis or treatment provided by a veterinarian. If your pet has a health concern or you need individual advice, always contact a veterinarian.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Health corner