Free delivery with parcel machines on orders 49 eur

Our Mental Health and Dogs: What Do They Really Give Us?

Back to Health corner
vaimne tervis

Our Mental Health and Dogs: What Do They Really Give Us?

Reading time: about 5 min

Sometimes the hardest thing in the world is doing something that doesn’t seem “useful”: sitting down for a moment, or going for a walk without trying to get five other things done at the same time. My daily walks with the dogs do wonders for my mental wellbeing when I actually let myself rest. Then it’s simply time spent moving together. Sometimes I listen to an uplifting podcast; sometimes I let my thoughts wander. But lately I’ve caught myself working during dog walks more and more often, updating blog articles as I go. And I notice that I’m more irritable than usual. I get especially annoyed when one of the dogs decides to spend five minutes reading the news at a particular bush, forcing me to slow down my work. That’s when I really need to look at myself and ask: “Why does this annoy me at all?”

But does feeling better around a dog mean that dog ownership automatically improves everyone’s mental health? Not quite. The subject is more interesting and more human than a big percentage in a research headline.

Companionship, Routine and the Chance to Be Present

In a 2023 survey by the American Psychiatric Association, 86% of pet owners said their pet had a mostly positive effect on their mental health. Responses from dog and cat owners were very similar, at 87% and 86% respectively. People most often mentioned companionship, love, a calming presence, and relief from stress and anxiety. But this was a survey of 2,200 American adults, not an experiment proving that getting a pet caused an improvement in wellbeing. Respondents described their own experiences. Those experiences matter, but they cannot establish causation on their own.

A dog often gives the day a rhythm. You have to go outside in the morning whether your work inbox is quiet or already on fire. A walk offers movement, daylight, a chance to notice your surroundings and occasionally a conversation with another person. All of these can support mental wellbeing. A dog’s contribution isn’t necessarily some mysterious “happiness hormone”; it may be a whole set of small daily habits. Nor does everyone need to adopt a dog for that reason. Volunteering at a shelter, walking a friend’s dog or arranging a regular walk with someone can offer some of the same benefits.

For some people, the most valuable thing is unconditional companionship. A dog doesn’t ask why you didn’t finish your work or why you’re so quiet today. They want their person, their familiar scent and the routine of being together. That doesn’t replace human relationships, but it can be a valuable anchor when the rest of the world feels too loud.

Why Can a Look or a Touch Change How We Feel?

The human-dog bond has also been studied at a biological level. In a 2015 study published in Science, Nagasawa and colleagues linked mutual gaze between dogs and their owners to changes in oxytocin levels. Oxytocin plays a part in social bonding, among other things. It’s fascinating research, but it does not show that looking into every dog’s eyes clinically reduces anxiety or cures depression. A measured hormone change and a person’s long-term mental health are different questions.

The same applies to petting and physical closeness. If your dog enjoys being touched, it may be a peaceful moment for you both. But we also need to read the dog’s body language: some dogs seek contact, while others need space. An animal isn’t a stress-relief device who must always provide affection on demand.

The Research Does Not Give One Simple Answer

A 2025 systematic review covering 116 studies found that stronger attachment to a pet was associated with better mental health in some studies, poorer mental health in others, and no clear relationship in some. Another 2025 meta-analysis, pooling 21 studies and more than 159,000 participants, found no overall statistically significant association between pet ownership and depression risk. These findings don’t invalidate anyone’s positive experience with their dog. They simply mean we cannot make one universal promise.

It also matters what a study is actually comparing. “Does this person own a dog?” is a very rough measure. It doesn’t tell us whether they walk together, whether the dog is healthy, how strong the bond is, whether the owner has a support network or whether the responsibilities of pet ownership are manageable at that moment. A well-functioning relationship can be a great source of support. During difficult times, that same strong bond can also make worries feel overwhelming.

When a Dog Is Ill, Love Can Come with a Heavy Burden

We talk less about this side of the story. When an animal has a chronic illness, there are medicines, test results, meals, walking tolerance and sometimes financial pressures to monitor. Even when we do all of it willingly, being constantly on alert can be mentally exhausting. A 2017 study by Spitznagel and colleagues involved 238 dog and cat owners. Compared with owners of healthy pets, people caring for chronically or seriously ill animals reported greater caregiver burden, more symptoms of anxiety and depression, and lower quality of life. As an observational study, it cannot attribute every difference solely to the animal’s illness, but it describes a very real problem.

There is a small paradox here. An animal who has been a source of peace for years may become our greatest worry during illness. That doesn’t mean the bond was wrong or that the dog has become a burden. It means the caregiver needs care too. Sometimes the most practical help is having someone else take the dog out for half an hour, help with a vet visit or simply listen.

A Dog Is Not a Treatment for Depression, but Can Be Part of a Recovery Routine

You sometimes hear that all someone needs to overcome depression is a dog, some exercise or a closer connection with nature. It isn’t that simple. Depression and anxiety disorders vary in severity and causes, and may require professional assessment and treatment. Walking a dog may support sleep and activity routines, create social contact and ease loneliness, but it does not replace necessary care. If someone can no longer manage everyday life, their condition is getting worse or they are having thoughts of self-harm, the answer isn’t simply a longer walk. It’s time to seek prompt support from people and healthcare professionals.

At the same time, we shouldn’t dismiss practical benefits just because we cannot turn them into a universal remedy. Feeling better after walking my dogs is a real experience. Research helps me understand what can and cannot be generalised from it.

A Practical FendaF Pause for Thought

Choose one walk this week during which you don’t try to accomplish anything else. Notice whether your mood, tension or clarity of thought changes afterwards. If caring for an ill dog has become overwhelming, arrange one concrete form of help before the next difficult day: a walk, transport or a couple of hours off. If distress persists or worsens, talk to your family doctor or a mental health professional.

Take Care of Yourself, Too

I once heard a thought in a podcast that stayed with me: health has to come first, because without it we cannot properly care for those we love most. I don’t think that’s selfish. If I have a dog at home who needs help, it’s especially important that I eat, sleep, move and ask for support when necessary. A caregiver doesn’t have to be brave every hour of the day.

If this topic resonates with you, I still recommend Johann Hari’s book Lost Connections (published in Estonian as Katkenud sidemed). It raises important questions about loneliness, social relationships and our environment. It deserves a critical reading, not treatment as proof that all forms of depression can be cured solely by changing our lifestyle or relationships.

Dogs don’t solve all our problems. But they can remind us of something that gets lost in a busy life: not every step has to take us somewhere further. Sometimes it’s enough just to step outside with a friend. And the hardest step may be the one from the sofa to the door.

Sources

American Psychiatric Association (2023). Americans Note Overwhelming Positive Mental Health Impact of Their Pets in New Poll. View source

Nagasawa M. et al. (2015). Oxytocin-gaze positive loop and the coevolution of human-dog bonds. Science. DOI: 10.1126/science.1261022. View source

Spitznagel M. B. et al. (2017). Caregiver burden in owners of a sick companion animal: a cross-sectional observational study. Veterinary Record. DOI: 10.1136/vr.104295. View source

Northrope et al. (2025). The Relationship Between Attachment to Pets and Mental Health and Wellbeing: A Systematic Review. Animals. View source

Pet ownership and risk of depression: a systematic review and meta-analysis (2025). View source


🐾 FendaF believes in informed choices

The purpose of the FendaF blog is not to tell you what you must do. Our aim is to share knowledge, introduce different evidence-based and integrative perspectives, and help you make more informed decisions for your pet.

Every animal is unique, and no article can replace a consultation, diagnosis or treatment provided by a veterinarian. If your pet has a health concern or you need individual advice, always contact a veterinarian.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Health corner