Free delivery with parcel machines on orders 49 eur

How capable is your dog? Toy names and dogs’ ability to learn

Back to Health corner
Dog with a ball – learning toy names

How capable is your dog? Toy names and dogs’ ability to learn

Reading time: about 5 min

If you tell your dog to ‘fetch the ball’, does he really bring back the ball? What happens if you ask for the duck, the tug toy or his favourite teddy bear? I have wondered about this for years because our dogs have had very different relationships with their toys. My previous dog, Bemmu, knew many of his toys by name. He had a teddy bear he slept with, and when I asked at bedtime where his teddy was, he went looking for it, sometimes right at the bottom of the toy box.

Faddu can distinguish his ball, tug toy and leopard even when he has been asleep. I have not consistently tried to teach him many more names. The same is true of Ossu: to be fair, I simply have not made the time to try. It would be rather unfair to declare one dog less capable than another if they have not had the same opportunities to learn. Still, one study made me curious about just how many object names our dogs might be able to remember.

What does it mean when a dog knows a toy’s name?

First we need to distinguish several things. A dog may learn that the word ‘ball’ predicts a lovely game, and that is perfectly useful in everyday life. But if we put several toys in front of him and ask him to bring one particular item, we are asking something more precise: can he distinguish the words and connect them to individual objects? Can he still do it when the toys are in a different place and the person does not point out the correct answer?

Dogs are remarkably observant of our gestures, posture and tone of voice. A dog that appears to understand a word may actually be following the person’s gaze or another cue. That does not diminish the skill. It simply means that if we want to investigate word learning, we should make the experiment as fair as possible.

Remembering object names is not the whole of canine intelligence, either. One dog is brilliant at reading people’s moods; another solves searching problems independently; another has an extraordinary nose; and a fourth learns movement patterns very quickly. When we test only toy vocabulary, we measure one ability, not the dog’s entire intelligence or ‘IQ’.

The study involving 40 dogs

A study published in Scientific Reports in 2021 examined whether dogs could learn the names of new toys with a relatively short training programme. Forty dogs participated. Thirty-four had no previously demonstrated vocabulary of toy names, while six were already known to distinguish objects by name. The dogs took part in a training programme lasting roughly three months.

All six dogs with an existing vocabulary passed the new task, along with one dog from the initially inexperienced group. That gave the researchers seven unusually gifted word learners. All seven were Border Collies, but other Border Collies in the study did not show the same performance. That distinction matters. It does not mean that every Border Collie can learn toy names, or that dogs of other breeds cannot. Rather, this kind of rapid, extensive learning of object names was rare in the sample studied.

Some gifted dogs learned dozens of toy names in the course of these studies. Later research focused specifically on dogs already known to have this ability, and some had much larger vocabularies. Headlines such as ‘dogs understand dozens of words’ are easy to share, but the abilities of exceptional subjects cannot automatically be generalised to an average family dog.

There is another important limit: the fact that some dogs did not solve the task within three months does not prove they could never learn the name of a toy. Motivation, the method of training, attention, previous experience and human cues could all influence the result. The study gave researchers good reason to investigate exceptional learners, but not a home test that produces a dog’s ‘intelligence percentage’.

Are Border Collies the smartest dogs?

Border Collies have a reputation for learning quickly, and many have been bred to work closely with people. Stanley Coren’s popular breed rankings for intelligence are also widely known, but they deserve caution. They largely concern aspects of working and obedience behaviour, rather than all forms of cognition. An independent dog may be a wonderful problem-solver even if he does not follow commands as eagerly as another breed.

What I particularly like about that 40-dog study is that members of the same breed were not at all identical. Seven gifted Border Collies do not make the others foolish, let alone a dog who would rather follow a scent trail than fetch toys. A dog’s capabilities are always a combination of many traits and experiences.

If someone chooses a dog solely because ‘that breed is very intelligent’, I would suggest another question: do I have the time, skills and interest to provide the activities that dog needs? A dog who learns very quickly may also become bored if everyday life is monotonous. Living with a clever dog is not just about enjoying fast tricks.

Try it at home: can your dog distinguish two toys?

This is a fun, low-risk activity you can try together. I would not call it a scientific test, but it can be a lovely way to learn as a team. Start with two clearly different toys your dog already likes. Call one ‘ball’ and the other ‘duck’, for example. Keep the names short and distinct in sound.

First, play with one toy and say its name naturally as you play. Praise or reward your dog when he touches it or brings it to you. Do the same separately with the other toy. Once he seems to grasp the association, place both on the floor and ask for one. Switch their positions occasionally so the answer does not depend on one toy always being on the left.

Do not constantly look at the correct toy or point to it. If possible, ask another family member to arrange the toys so even you do not know their positions. That reduces the chance that the dog is reading your body language. But everyday play does not need to become a laboratory. If your dog makes a mistake, make the task easier and give him more time rather than becoming disappointed.

FendaF’s little toy challenge:

Choose two different toys and teach their names in short games over several days. Notice whether your dog can distinguish them even when you swap their positions. If he loses interest or becomes uncertain, stop for now and try a simpler version later. You can write down which words and situations work best. The real win is having fun together.

Talent is not the same as obedience, and learning is not a competition

I would hate our home experiment to become another opportunity to compare dogs like school exam results. One dog may enjoy learning toy names, another nose-work games, another exploring new trails on a hike. What matters is that the dog takes part willingly and his body language shows interest. If the game becomes frustrating or too difficult, we have not really taught him anything useful.

Yet curiosity about what dogs can learn is entirely justified. Exceptional word learners give researchers a fascinating opening to explore how words are associated with objects and the role of rare talent. Not every dog has to aim for the same result. I prefer another thought: we do not always know what our own dog is particularly good at until we try.

In conclusion

Bemmu’s teddy bear, Faddu’s ball, tug toy and leopard, and Ossu’s still-undiscovered toy vocabulary are all part of my own stories with dogs. The 2021 study showed that some dogs possess truly exceptional abilities to learn object names. It did not prove that a dog’s worth can be counted in words, or that one breed is superior in every way.

I still want to try this game with Faddu and Ossu one day. Not to find out who ‘wins’, but to see what they might teach me while learning themselves. And if we only learn the name of one more toy, we will still have gained another lovely experience together.

Read also: Noise phobia in dogs.

Sources

Fugazza, C. et al. Word learning dogs (Canis familiaris) provide an animal model for studying exceptional performance. Scientific Reports (2021), 11, 14070.

Fugazza, C. et al. Rapid learning of object names in dogs. Scientific Reports (2021), 11, 2222.

Dror, S. et al. A citizen science model turns anecdotes into evidence by revealing similar characteristics among Gifted Word Learner dogs. Scientific Reports (2023), 13, 21747.


🐾 FendaF believes in informed choices

The purpose of the FendaF blog is not to tell you what you must do. Our aim is to share knowledge, introduce different evidence-based and integrative perspectives, and help you make more informed decisions for your pet.

Every animal is unique, and no article can replace a consultation, diagnosis or treatment provided by a veterinarian. If your pet has a health concern or you need individual advice, always contact a veterinarian.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Health corner